| Champion | Won | Lost | Days Held | Notes |
| Eric James | 4/13/2019 | – | – | 2x champion
(first reign 112 days) |
| Steve Gibki | 6/23/2019 | 4/13/2019 | 294 | |
| Jay Delta | 1/13/2018 | 6/23/2018 | 161 | |
| Fighter Cat | 6/4/2016 | 1/13/2018 | 588 | |
| VSK | 7/25/2015 | 6/4/2016 | 315 | 2x champion
(700 combined days) |
| Jorge Santi | 8/16/2014 | 7/25/2015 | 343 | Kevin Tibbs put championship on the line in the Gold Rush Rumble match |
| Kevin Tibbs | 5/31/2014 | 8/16/2014 | 77 | |
| EJ Risk | 2/8/2014 | 5/31/2014 | 112 | |
| Kai Katana | 5/18/2013 | 2/8/2014 | 266 | |
| Kevin Fulton | 12/3/2011 | 5/18/2013 | 532 | |
| Ricky Reyes | 10/9/2010 | 12/3/2011 | 420 | |
| VSK | 9/19/2009 | 10/9/2010 | 385 | |
| Sabotage | 2/28/2009 | 9/19/2009 | 203 | |
| VACATED | 2/28/2009 | | | Nick Noshus stripped of championship |
| Nick Noshus | 1/10/2009 | 2/28/2009 | 49 | Winner of Gold Rush Rumble match to determine first champion |
