| Champion | Won | Lost | Days Held | Notes |
| The Unwilting Tatiana | 10/14/2023 | | | |
| Valentina Vasquez | 12/18/2021 | 10/14/2023 | 666 | Valentina attacked The Unforgiven Salem before the match to keep her from the triple threat match, but with the referee tending to Tatiana, Salem attacked Valentina. |
| Karen BamBam | 1/11/2020 | 12/18/2021 | 210* | [CDC guidelines as a result of COVID-19 shut down all sports in New York March 2020 to July 2021. Reign to include active dates only.] |
| Ariela Nyx | 2/19/2019 | 1/11/2020 | 326 | Defeated Eris Spiral in tournament finals |
| Vacated | 1/19/2019 | | | Masha Slamovich stripped of championship |
| Masha Slamovich | 9/22/2018 | 1/19/2019 | 120 | |
| “The Alien” Kris Statlander | 6/23/2018 | 9/22/2018 | 91 | 2x champion
(469 combined)
Falls count anywhere match restarted by Commissioner Fulton |
| Sam L’Eterna | 6/23/2018 | 6/23/2018 | <1 | Sam L’Eterna won the championship in a match after double teaming Statlander with partner Antoinette Marie. |
| “White Girl” Kris Statlander | 6/10/2017 | 6/23/2018 | 378 | |
| Karen Q | 4/30/2016 | 6/10/2017 | 406 | |
| Nikki Addams | 6/6/2015 | 4/30/2016 | 329 | |
