Nick Noshus
January 10, 2009 to February 28, 2009
49 days

January 10, 2009: Nick Noshus defeated VSK, Sabotage & Jorge Santi in a fatal fourway. Those four were the final 4 men left at the end of the first ever VPW Gold Rush Rumble which featured 20 wrestlers.

Title Defenses:
January 24, 2009: Big Vito
February 28, 2009: Nick Noshus is stripped of the title by the New York State Athletic Commission due to injuries.

Sabotage
February 28, 2009 to September 19, 2009
202 days

February 28, 2009: After Nick Noshus was stripped, Sabotage won a match that also included Xavier and VSK. Joe So Delicious won a match that also included Minyon, Jorge Santi and Javi-Air. Sabotage then defeated Joe So Delicious to win the vacant New York Championship.

Title Defenses:
March 13, 2009: “Smooth Operator” Mike Gallagher
May 9, 2009: Richie Tyler
June 27, 2009: Nightmare
July 11, 2009: VSK (VSK won by DQ, but Sabotage retained)
August 8, 2009: “Suburban Bad Boy” Joey Everlast
September 12, 2009: “Firebird” Jorge Santi
September 19, 2009: Defeated by VSK

VsK
September 19, 2009 to October 9th, 2010
385 days

September 19, 2009: VSK defeated Sabotage.

Title Defenses:
October 24, 2009: E.J. Risk
November 14th, 2009: Sabotage in a Ladder Match
December 12th, 2009: Romeo Roselli
January 16th, 2010: Minyon
January 16th, 2010: Sabotage
January 16th, 2010: Minyon
January 30th, 2010: Johnny ‘Muscles’ Marinara
March 6th, 2010: Romeo Roselli
May 1st, 2010: E.J. Risk
May 15th, 2010: Match with E.J. Risk ended in a No Contest
July 24th, 2010: E.J. Risk
July 30th, 2010: Reggaedones & Jonny “Muscles” Marinara (Triple Threat Elimination)
August 21st, 2010: “Slick Sleezy” Sam Shaw
September 11th, 2010: Jay Delta
October 9th, 2010: Defeated By Ricky Reyes

Ricky Reyes
October 9th, 2010 to December 3rd, 2011
420 days

October 9th, 2010: Ricky Reyes defeated VSK

Title Defenses:
November 20th, 2010: VSK won by DQ, but Rick Reyes retained the championship
December 4th, 2010: Flames
February 19th, 2011: K Fresh
March 19th, 2011: VSK
May 21st, 2011: K-Funk
June 4th, 2011: Jorge Santi & Amazing Red
September 17th, 2011: Amazing Red
October 8th, 2011:  K-Fresh Kevin Fulton
December 3rd, 2011: Defeated by Kevin Fulton inside a 15-foot high steel cage.

“K-Fresh” Kevin Fulton
December 3rd, 2011 to Present

December 3rd, 2011: Both Ricky Reyes and Kevin Fulton tried to pin, submit, and escape to win this match inside a 15-foot high steel cage, but without Conflux to help interfere, the then-longest reigning New York State Champion finally lost to Fulton.

Title Defenses:
January 14, 2012: VPW Champion Josef Von Schmidt (won by DQ)
February 4, 2012: Jay Delta in a Blindfold match
March 10, 2012: Jay Delta
March 31, 2012: Xander Page
May 11, 2012: Razzle Dazzle
May 11, 2012: Jay Delta
May 19, 2012: “The Heartthrob” Romeo Roselli
June 30, 2012: “The Heartthrob” Romeo Roselli – double count out
September 22, 2012: Jason Static (w/ MISTER Tibbs and Jacob Hendrix)
October 6, 2012: Kai Katana (w/ MISTER Tibbs and Jacob Hendrix)
March 23, 2013: Dorian Graves(w/ Jacob Hendrix)